In the skincare industry, “collagen creams” often promise to enhance the elasticity and youthful appearance of the skin. However, their efficacy is frequently questioned. The allure of these products, which often highlight “collagen” on their labels, may be more about marketing than substantial scientific evidence.
The Reality of Collagen Creams
According to board-certified dermatologist Nancy Samolitis, co-founder of Facile Skin, collagen creams and supplements may not deliver the results consumers expect. “There is no evidence that collagen creams or supplements benefit skin,” she states. Collagen molecules are too large to penetrate the skin when applied topically, and oral collagen supplements are broken down by stomach acids before they can have any effect.
The Positive Aspects
Despite these limitations, some collagen creams can still be beneficial. Board-certified dermatologist Marisa Garshick notes that while collagen itself may not be effective, certain creams can offer advantages. “Collagen cream primarily moisturizes the skin, providing a plumping effect that can make the skin appear smoother and healthier,” she explains. Additionally, some formulations contain hydrolyzed collagen, or collagen peptides, which can penetrate the skin more effectively and potentially enhance the skin’s barrier and support collagen production.
For those interested in incorporating collagen creams into their skincare routine, here are ten highly recommended options, vetted by dermatologists and praised by users.
Top-Rated Collagen Creams
1.Ultra Repair Firming Collagen Cream
Best Overall: First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Firming Collagen Cream
Price: $44 at Ulta Beauty, $39 at Amazon, $44 at Nordstrom
Pros: Non-comedogenic, available in a jumbo size
Cons: None noted
Garshick recommends this cream for its combination of peptides and niacinamide, which help firm the skin and improve elasticity while providing deep hydration. It’s suitable for all skin types, including sensitive.
2.Firming Collagen Day Lotion
Best Deal: TruSkin Firming Collagen Day Lotion
Price: $20 at Amazon, $18 at truskin.com
Pros: Affordable, paraben and sulfate-free
Cons: Small size
This lotion contains ceramides and vegan collagen peptides, making it a good choice for dry skin types. It’s praised for its affordability and effectiveness.
3.Collagen Bank Daily Face Moisturizer with SPF 30
Best With SPF: Neutrogena Collagen Bank Daily Face Moisturizer with SPF 30
Price: $30 at Ulta Beauty, $30 at Amazon
Pros: Affordable, broad-spectrum SPF 30, fragrance-free
Cons: None noted
This moisturizer combines micro-peptides with SPF 30, providing hydration and sun protection. It is noted for its lightweight formula that doesn’t clog pores.
4.Nourishing Moisturizer
Best For Combination Skin: Solawave Nourishing Moisturizer
Price: $36 at solawave.co
Pros: Oil-free, petroleum-free
Cons: May not be hydrating enough for very dry skin
This product is recommended for combination skin and features a blend of peptides, hyaluronic acid, and polyglutamic acid to boost moisture and strengthen the skin barrier.
5.Regenerist Collagen Peptide 24 Face Moisturizer
Best Drugstore Find: Olay Regenerist Collagen Peptide 24 Face Moisturizer
Price: $30 at CVS, $28 at Walmart
Pros: Affordable, fragrance-free
Cons: None noted
Garshick appreciates this moisturizer for its ability to hydrate and plump the skin, using collagen peptides and niacinamide to support moisture retention and soothe the skin.
6.Pro-Collagen Marine Cream
Best For Mature Skin: Elemis Pro-Collagen Marine Cream
Price: $140 at Revolve, $140 at Amazon, $70 at Walmart
Pros: Award-winning, lightweight gel-cream texture
Cons: Expensive
Known for its marine-derived collagen, this cream hydrates and improves skin elasticity, offering a smoother and more youthful appearance.
7.Pep Up Collagen Boost Face & Neck Serum
Best For Face & Neck: Colorscience Pep Up Collagen Boost Face & Neck Serum
Price: $179 at colorescience.com, $179 at Amazon
Pros: Designed for face and neck, award-winning, non-comedogenic
Cons: High price
This serum targets both face and neck, using peptides to enhance collagen production and improve skin firmness.
8.Restore & Renew Face & Neck Multi Action Night Cream
Best Night Cream: No7 Restore & Renew Face & Neck Multi Action Night Cream
Price: $33 at Ulta Beauty, $29 at Amazon, $50 at Walmart
Pros: Affordable
Cons: Subtle fragrance
Recommended for its combination of collagen peptides and antioxidants, this night cream helps restore firmness and soften fine lines.
9.Retinol Correxion Under Eye Cream
Best Eye Cream: RoC Retinol Correxion Under Eye Cream
Price: $19 at Amazon, $30 at Ulta Beauty
Pros: Affordable, dermatologist-tested, non-greasy
Cons: None noted
This eye cream uses retinol to stimulate collagen production and strengthen the skin’s barrier, offering a budget-friendly option for targeting under-eye concerns.
10.Pro-Collagen Banking Serum
Best Lightweight Serum: Dermalogica Pro-Collagen Banking Serum
Price: $89 at Blue Mercury
Pros: Lightweight texture, hygienic pump applicator
Cons: Less hydrating than a cream
This gel serum protects and preserves the skin’s collagen using a blend of amino acids and antioxidants.
Expert Opinions
Dermatologists agree that collagen creams do not build new collagen but can aid in moisturizing the skin. Dr. Heather Rogers advises using creams with ingredients that support the skin barrier and prevent inflammation. For boosting collagen levels, retinoids, vitamin C, and in-office treatments like microneedling are recommended.
Conclusion
Collagen creams can be a valuable part of a skincare regimen, particularly for their moisturizing and plumping effects. While they may not directly increase collagen production, choosing the right product with supportive ingredients can improve skin texture and appearance.
Related topics:
Essential Skincare Tips for the Monsoon Season
Sun Damage: The Primary Threat to Skin Health and How to Combat It
Hydration and Skin Health: How Eating Certain Foods Can Boost Your Glow
