In recent years, non-surgical facial rejuvenation procedures have gained popularity. Two of the most talked-about treatments are face threading and Botox. While both aim to reduce the signs of aging, they work in entirely different ways and come with their own set of benefits and risks. Understanding these differences is key to determining which option is better for you.
What is Face Threading?
Face threading, or thread lifts, is a cosmetic procedure designed to lift sagging skin and redefine facial contours. The treatment involves inserting polydioxanone (PDO) threads into the skin through a needle. These threads act as scaffolding under the skin, lifting and tightening areas that have lost elasticity due to aging.
The threads are made of a biodegradable material that dissolves over time. However, they stimulate collagen production in the treated area, promoting natural skin rejuvenation long after the threads have dissolved.
Types of Threads
There are different types of threads used in this procedure, and each serves a unique purpose:
Mono threads: These are smooth threads used primarily for collagen stimulation. They don’t lift the skin but improve its texture and firmness.
Cog threads: These threads have barbs or hooks that anchor the skin. They are more effective at providing an immediate lift.
Screw threads: Used in areas that need more volume, such as the cheeks. Screw threads provide both lift and volume enhancement.
How Does Face Threading Work?
The procedure begins with local anesthesia to numb the area being treated. The surgeon or practitioner inserts the threads into the skin using fine needles. Once inserted, the threads are pulled tight, lifting the skin and securing it in place.
This process can take 30 to 90 minutes, depending on the number of threads used and the areas being treated. The procedure is generally well tolerated with minimal downtime, allowing most patients to return to their normal activities within a few days.
Face threading can target various parts of the face, including:
Forehead and brow to lift sagging brows.
Cheeks to restore lost volume and contour.
Jawline to redefine sagging skin.
Neck to improve laxity and create a more defined appearance.
How Does Botox Work?
Botox, or Botulinum toxin, is a neurotoxin that works by temporarily paralyzing muscles. When injected into targeted muscles, Botox blocks the release of a chemical called acetylcholine, which signals the muscles to contract. By inhibiting muscle activity, Botox smooths out wrinkles and fine lines caused by facial expressions like smiling or frowning.
Common Areas Treated with Botox
Botox is commonly used to treat dynamic wrinkles, which are caused by repeated muscle movement. These areas include:
- Forehead lines
- Crow’s feet around the eyes
- Frown lines (also known as the “11s”) between the eyebrows
- Lip lines or “smoker’s lines”
- Chin dimpling
- Neck bands (also called platysmal bands)
How Long Does Botox Last?
The effects of Botox are temporary, generally lasting between 3 to 6 months. Over time, the treated muscles regain function as the body naturally metabolizes the toxin. This means maintenance treatments are required to sustain results.
Botox does not affect the skin’s texture or elasticity directly but helps in reducing the appearance of wrinkles by minimizing muscle contractions.
See also: Is Botox Harmful Over Time?
Pros and Cons of Face Threading vs. Botox
While both face threading and Botox can address signs of aging, they differ significantly in their methods, duration, and areas of effectiveness.
Advantages of Face Threading
Immediate Results: The lifting effect of face threading is noticeable almost immediately, and the results improve over time as collagen production increases.
Longer-lasting Results: Unlike Botox, which needs to be repeated every few months, the effects of face threading can last up to 1 to 3 years depending on the type of threads used.
Natural Rejuvenation: Thread lifts stimulate collagen production, which enhances skin firmness and elasticity over time. This makes the results look more natural.
Minimal Downtime: Although there may be some swelling and bruising, most people can resume normal activities within 24 to 48 hours after the procedure.
Disadvantages of Face Threading
Invasive Procedure: While not as invasive as traditional surgery, face threading is still more invasive than Botox, as it involves the insertion of multiple threads under the skin.
Risks of Infection: As with any procedure that punctures the skin, there is a risk of infection or complications if not performed properly.
Not Suitable for Everyone: Individuals with extremely thin or sagging skin may not benefit as much from face threading, as the lift may not be sufficient.
Advantages of Botox
Non-invasive: Botox involves only injections, making it less invasive than face threading. The procedure is quick and requires no downtime.
Effective for Dynamic Wrinkles: Botox is highly effective for smoothing wrinkles caused by muscle movement, such as frown lines and crow’s feet.
Safe with a Proven Track Record: Botox has been used in cosmetic treatments for decades and has a well-documented safety profile when administered by a trained professional.
Disadvantages of Botox
Temporary Results: One of the biggest drawbacks is that Botox needs to be repeated every few months to maintain results.
Limited Effectiveness on Sagging Skin: Botox does not address sagging or loose skin. It is primarily effective for wrinkles caused by muscle movement, not for loss of volume or skin laxity.
Muscle Weakness: Overuse of Botox can lead to temporary muscle weakness or a “frozen” appearance, which may look unnatural.
Face Threading vs. Botox: Which One is More Effective?
The effectiveness of face threading versus Botox depends on several factors, including the patient’s age, skin condition, and specific aesthetic goals.
For Younger Individuals (30s to Early 40s)
Botox is typically more effective for younger individuals who are primarily concerned with dynamic wrinkles. If the main goal is to smooth out forehead lines or crow’s feet, Botox is often the better option.
Face Threading can also be a viable option for individuals in their 30s or 40s who are starting to experience mild sagging but don’t yet require a full facelift. Threading can provide a subtle lift and boost collagen production.
For Middle-aged Individuals (Mid-40s to 50s)
Face Threading becomes more effective for those in their 40s and 50s who are starting to experience more noticeable sagging and volume loss. At this stage, a combination of threading and dermal fillers might provide optimal results.
Botox can still be used to treat dynamic wrinkles, but it may not address the underlying issue of skin laxity as effectively.
For Older Individuals (60s and Above)
Face Threading may not be as effective in individuals with significant skin laxity or deep wrinkles. In such cases, surgical facelifts might provide more substantial results.
Botox can still be used to treat specific areas, but older individuals may require more comprehensive treatments to address multiple signs of aging.
Cost Comparison
Face Threading Cost
The cost of face threading varies depending on the number of threads used and the practitioner’s expertise. On average, it can range from $1,500 to $4,500 per session. The longevity of the results means that patients may only need to undergo the procedure once every 1 to 3 years.
Botox Cost
Botox is generally more affordable per session, with prices ranging from $200 to $600 per treatment area. However, because Botox needs to be repeated every few months, the long-term costs can add up significantly.
Side Effects and Recovery Time
Face Threading
Swelling and Bruising: Mild swelling, bruising, and discomfort are common after a thread lift. These symptoms usually subside within a few days.
Infection Risk: Although rare, there is a risk of infection, especially if proper aftercare is not followed.
Downtime: Most patients can resume normal activities within a day or two. However, it is advised to avoid strenuous activities for at least a week.
Botox
Bruising and Swelling: Some patients may experience mild bruising or swelling at the injection sites, but these symptoms usually subside quickly.
Temporary Drooping: In rare cases, Botox can cause temporary drooping of the eyelid or brow if injected too close to these areas.
Minimal Downtime: Most patients can return to their normal routines immediately after the procedure, with no need for downtime.
Conclusion
When deciding between face threading and Botox, the answer depends on your specific needs and goals. If you’re primarily concerned with dynamic wrinkles and want a quick, non-invasive solution, Botox may be the better option. However, if you’re looking to address sagging skin and desire longer-lasting results, face threading could be the right choice.
In many cases, a combination of both treatments can provide optimal results. Consulting with a qualified medical professional can help you determine the best approach for your individual skin type, age, and aesthetic preferences.
Related topic:
Is face waxing better than threading: [Revealed!]
